Tax Blog – Termination Payments
26th November 2024

Tax Blog – Termination Payments
A termination payment can be subject to certain income tax exemptions; however, understanding when these apply can be difficult. It is vital that employers take advice on these complex issues to avoid an income tax and national insurance contributions (NIC) under deduction assessment being raised by HMRC. In this blog, we discuss how termination payments can be taxed.
It is common for employers to use settlement agreements to reach an agreement with the employee to potentially avoid an employment tribunal. Careful analysis of any agreement covering the payment and its constituent components is required. We have a vast wealth of experience in helping employers with their income tax and NIC compliance in relation to termination payments.
Generally, termination payments can be grouped as:
Payments subject to income tax and NICs
These include:
- Earnings
- Restrictive undertakings
- Benefits from an employer-financed retirement benefits scheme (EFRBS)
Earnings will include deferred remuneration, such as a delayed payment of salary, contractual payments, such as payments in lieu of notice (PILONs) and payments made due to custom and practice. These payments are treated as ‘general earnings’ and will also be subject to NIC.
Payments that impose some sort of restriction on the employee post-employment, e.g. not being able to work for a direct competitor for a period of time, are also subject to tax/NIC as general earnings.
An EFRBS is defined as a scheme for the provision of benefits that consists of or includes relevant benefits. Generally, these have been associated with complex tax planning schemes, however, the wide nature of the definition of an EFRBS means that sometimes ‘vanilla’ planning may be caught.
Care should be taken where an employee nearing retirement is provided with a ‘relevant’ benefit and the payment is expressly in relation to their retirement.
Payments that are potentially income tax exempt
Where a payment does not fit into one of the above categories, it is likely to fall within the overall £30,000 income tax exemption threshold (Section 401 onwards ITEPA 2003). This can include the following:
- Benefits in kind
- Compensation
- Damages (e.g. for breach of contract where there was a failure to give proper notice)
- Payments under employment protection and non-discrimination legislation made in connection with the termination of employment
- Statutory redundancy payments
- Non-statutory redundancy payments
- Ex-gratia payments
Compensation and damages payments that are not treated as earnings, will generally fall within S.401. In a settlement agreement, apportioning payments to specific items rather than a global compensatory sum is important to protect against a HMRC challenge.
Ex gratia payments require careful consideration as the terminology can mean different things. We recommend that we review all settlement agreements for employment taxes issues, to give certainty that your tax compliance obligations are met.
Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP)
Where any part of a contractual notice period is not worked and a payment is agreed between employer and employee, there is a requirement to consider the post-employment notice pay (PENP) rules, and use the statutory formula to calculate the amount that will be treated as ‘earnings’ instead of being eligible for the £30,000 tax exemption. This should be applied to the value of payments within S.401 detailed above (except statutory redundancy pay) with the remainder then exempt from tax up to £30,000.
The rules on PENP are complex, and we would advise you to consider attending one of our specialist training sessions which covers PENP in detail.
Payments that are fully exempt
Payments under the following will be fully exempt from income tax/NIC subject to certain criteria:
- Death
- Injury or disability
- Lump sum payments under a tax-exempt pension scheme
- Payments into a registered pension scheme
- Hurt feelings (in limited circumstances such as, as part of a discrimination claim, if the discrimination does not arise from the termination)
Employer Reporting
Where a termination award that includes non-cash benefits exceeds £30,000 in total, the employer is required to prepare and submit a report to HMRC by 6 July following the end of the tax year, and give a copy to the employee. This report will detail the total payments and benefits awarded, and will include an estimate of the total number of tax years which the benefit will be provided.
Benefits will continue to be reported on the P11D(b) with Class 1A NIC due as normal. Further rules around the calculation of the benefits in later years apply, please contact us for further information.
NIC
Where a termination award is made on or after 6 April 2020, which exceeds the £30,000 threshold, the excess amount will be subject to employer’s Class 1A NIC, however, this is collected via the payroll rather than on the P11D(b). There is no employees NIC due on the excess amount.
Contact us for help and advice before the termination payment is made, so that we can advise how a settlement can be made in the most efficient way.
