Mainpay Ltd – Importance of Seeking Professional Advice

Reasonable Care: The importance of seeking the right tax advice

The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment on this case on 10 October 2025.  The case concerned an appeal by Mainpay Ltd (‘Mainpay’), an umbrella company employing temporary workers, against decisions of the Upper Tribunal (UT) and First-tier Tribunal (FTT), both of which had upheld determinations by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC). HMRC had disallowed tax deductions for “subsistence expenses” paid to Mainpay’s workers and issued assessments for unpaid income tax. The Court of Appeal, dismissed all of Mainpay’s appeals in relation to the following three central issues:

  1. Whether workers’ successive temporary assignments formed part of one overarching employment or constituted separate employments.
  2. Whether an employer may reimburse employees using reasonable estimates of expenses rather than receipts.
  3. Whether HMRC’s assessments for two tax years were out of time, or whether the “loss of tax” had been brought about carelessly by Mainpay, extending the statutory limitation period.

This blog focuses specifically on issue 3.

What Mainpay argued

Mainpay said that the FTT had wrongly decided that any tax loss was “brought about carelessly”. If that finding was incorrect, HMRC would only have had four years to assess. Mainpay also claimed that it had taken advice and, therefore, had taken reasonable care. It further argued that HMRC’s case did not set out causation clearly enough.

The advice Mainpay relied on

The advice Mainpay received came from a well-regarded law firm. However, the firm did not specialise in tax, was not given all the relevant information, and was only asked to comment on the form of the contract and the ability to reimburse “deductible business expenditure”. This was very different from asking whether the specific subsistence expenses paid under that contract were tax-deductible.

The judge also noted that Mainpay already had a separate tax adviser who advised on expenses, yet that adviser appeared not to have been consulted on this issue. The tribunals concluded that reasonable care had not been taken because the advice sought was not appropriate for the question that needed to be answered.

The question of causation

Mainpay said that HMRC needed to set out a full “counterfactual” scenario showing exactly what would have happened if Mainpay had acted differently. Their argument relied on the wording in the legislation that a loss of tax is brought about carelessly if the person “fails to take reasonable care to avoid bringing about that loss”.

The UT disagreed with Mainpay’s interpretation. The UT accepted that HMRC needed to show a link between the carelessness and the loss of tax, but confirmed that this did not require a detailed alternative scenario. The keyword is “avoid”. Carelessness exists where reasonable steps could have prevented the issue. Examples include:

  • Failing to seek advice on a material point when advice could have been taken.
  • Relying on advice from a source that was not suitable for the question in hand.

In either case, the loss could have been avoided by taking advice from an appropriate tax specialist.

Why this matters

The judgment highlights the importance of seeking the right professional advice when dealing with tax matters. Mainpay’s failure to take reasonable care arose because it did not obtain guidance from a qualified tax adviser on the point that caused the tax loss.

Our clients have unlimited access to our specialist employment taxes helpline. As this case shows, taking proper advice can help prevent extended HMRC assessment time limits and reduce risk when reviewing historic issues.

Contact the PSTAX Employment Taxes Team

If you would like to discuss how the Mainpay case affects your organisation or want support on reasonable care and assessment time limits, our employment taxes team is here to help.

Get in touch

Alex Gardner

Written by Alex Gardner

Alex brings over 21 years of experience in tax to PSTAX, specialising in the intricacies of employment tax. His focus on private client and employment taxes allows him to provide comprehensive guidance across a wide range of areas, including: Employment Tax Advisory: Alex tackles complex issues like IR35, off-payroll working, CIS and global mobility. Compliance Expertise: His deep technical knowledge and proven track record in employment tax compliance ensure your business stays on the right side of regulations.

View all by Alex Gardner