Case Study: IR35 and Off-Payroll Working Challenges for Local Councils

Supporting Councils with HMRC’s Off-Payroll (IR35) Reviews

HMRC’s LAUPSTREAM1 Campaign

In 2023, HMRC launched the LAUPSTREAM1 campaign as part of its wider focus on IR35 and off-payroll working in the public sector. Councils across the UK were asked to provide details of the self-employed individuals and off-payroll workers they engaged.

HMRC had already identified that many authorities were paying a category of trainers as non-employees. These councils were offered an amnesty: they could move the trainers onto payroll without retrospective penalties.

HMRC’s View of Employment Status

HMRC argued that trainers should be considered employed for tax purposes. Their reasoning was based on key factors:

  • Personal service was required (trainers could not send substitutes),

  • A framework of control existed around how the work was delivered, and

  • Trainers bore little or no financial risk when fulfilling their contracts.

Councils’ Concerns and Risks

Some councils took a different view. They argued that trainers were genuinely self-employed because:

  • They were not under mutual obligation — they could refuse work,

  • They often had multiple end clients, especially with the rise of remote working, and

  • Many had other private sources of income.

This left councils exposed to significant tax risk. If HMRC’s view prevailed, authorities could have faced large retrospective liabilities.

PSTAX’s Support for Local Councils

PSTAX represented several councils during the campaign. We:

  • Presented councils’ reasoning for treating trainers as self-employed,

  • Demonstrated the structured processes they had followed,

  • Highlighted employment status policies and procedures we had advised on, and

  • Showcased employment status training we had delivered to council staff.

This approach gave HMRC clear evidence that councils had acted responsibly and with due diligence in reaching their conclusions.

Negotiating Practical Solutions with HMRC

Our negotiations ensured that no retrospective action was taken, even where HMRC disagreed with a council’s determination. Instead, councils were granted a period of grace to onboard trainers via payroll. This outcome reduced the immediate risk and gave councils assurance that their employment status procedures were both robust and defensible.

Key Learning for Local Councils

This case demonstrates the importance of:

  • Maintaining clear, up-to-date employment status policies,

  • Carrying out proactive reviews of off-payroll engagements, and

  • Engaging with HMRC early where disagreements arise.

It also shows the value of having specialist IR35 advisers who understand the local council context and can achieve practical, compliant solutions.

Next Steps

If your council is concerned about IR35 compliance, employment status reviews, or HMRC challenges, PSTAX can help. Contact our team today or learn more about the Local Council Tax Club to access expert advice, dedicated helplines, and tailored support for local councils.

Get in touch with the team today

Christine Robinson

Written by Christine Robinson

View all by Christine Robinson