Employment Tax issues when moving from taxis to council-provided transport

Potential employment tax issues when shifting from using taxis for home-to-school transport to providing vehicles for drivers

Home-to-school transport: a rising cost burden

The National Audit Office (NAO) has recently released a report on “Home to school transport”, which highlights how spending by local authorities on transporting children and young people to school or college in England has grown significantly.

Some of the key points include:

  • In 2023-24, local authorities spent around £2.32 billion transporting an estimated 520,000 children and young people.
  • There has been a 70% increase in spending between 2015-16 and 2023-24.
  • The estimated median annual cost per pupil on transport for children (aged 0–16 years) with SEND, is £8,116, compared with £1,526 for mainstream transport

Due to these pressures, we are seeing that some local authorities are exploring alternatives to contracted taxis and transport operators.  An example of an alternative is for the local authority to use their own fleet of vehicles with employed drivers, rather than relying purely on external taxi provision. That operational shift brings potential employment tax implications which often receive less attention than the cost of the contracts themselves.

When a driver gets a “company vehicle” instead of taxi provision: tax implications

Let’s imagine a scenario: rather than contracting taxis or having a driver use their own vehicle under a contract, the local authority provides the driver with a dedicated vehicle for the school-runs. On the face of it, this may seem efficient: fixed fleet, better control, possibly lower unit cost. However, from an employment tax perspective, there are important implications for both the employer and employee.

Benefit in Kind risk

If a vehicle is provided for an employee’s use (even if primarily for work) and the employee is able to use it for private journeys, then HMRC regard that as a benefit in kind (“company car”). The employee will have to pay income tax on the value of that benefit, and the employer will have to pay employer’s National Insurance contributions on the same value.

So, in our school-transport model, if the driver is provided a vehicle in which they commute and use for non-school journeys, this could attract car benefit in kind liability.

Why this matters in the context of home-to-school transport

Given the NAO’s finding that home-to-school transport costs are rising, local authorities are under pressure to find new models of delivery. If a shift to fleet-vehicles or directly employed drivers is on the table, the tax/employment cost dimension must be included in the business-case.

There is a very real risk of an unplanned tax/NIC and administration costs from switching from taxi contracts company vehicles.  There is also a risk that drivers may resist a model that results in them being taxed on a benefit they consider part of their job equipment.

Conclusion

The NAO’s report highlights a big sector cost pressure for local authorities in delivering statutory school transport duties. At the same time, for authorities exploring alternative delivery models such as providing vehicles directly to drivers rather than continuing taxi contract models, it is vital to capture the employment tax and benefit in kind implications.

A vehicle provided to a driver is not just a logistical or operational decision. It is a tax structure decision. Unless private use is tightly controlled and the model carefully operated, the company vehicle could become an expensive liability rather than a cost saver.

Contact the team

Alex Gardner

Written by Alex Gardner

Alex brings over 21 years of experience in tax to PSTAX, specialising in the intricacies of employment tax. His focus on private client and employment taxes allows him to provide comprehensive guidance across a wide range of areas, including: Employment Tax Advisory: Alex tackles complex issues like IR35, off-payroll working, CIS and global mobility. Compliance Expertise: His deep technical knowledge and proven track record in employment tax compliance ensure your business stays on the right side of regulations.

View all by Alex Gardner